Marblehead conditionally approves portion of 140-unit Glover Farmhouse development

The Marblehead Planning Board voted unanimously Nov. 19 to conditionally approve the town’s portion of a proposed 140-unit apartment development near Vinnin Square that would preserve the historic General John Glover farmhouse.

The project, proposed by Glover LLC for 202-204 Tedesco St., would include 44 apartments in Marblehead and 96 in Swampscott. Swampscott’s Planning Board has also given conditional approval.

The development would feature six residential buildings, three in each town, along with underground parking, landscaped open space and amenities including a clubhouse and swimming pool.

The proposal replaces a 140-unit development approved in 2023 (but never built) that would have demolished the farmhouse, which dates to approximately 1750. The new design has drawn support from historic preservation advocates who have spent years fighting to save the building.

Planning Board members praised the revised project but raised concerns about building heights, inconsistencies in architectural drawings and unresolved infrastructure questions.

The board’s approval is contingent on the developer submitting corrected plans and satisfying conditions outlined in a Nov. 17 staff report. Members are expected to review the revised drawings at their Dec. 8 meeting.

A new approach to a controversial site

A slide from Glover LCC’s presentation to the Marblehead Planning Board on Nov. 19.

Attorney Gerry D’Ambrosio, representing Glover LLC, described the proposal as a substantial improvement over the previously approved development.

The earlier project, proposed by Leggat McCall, would have placed much of its parking above ground and removed the farmhouse. The new plan calls for 232 parking spaces, including 88 serving the Marblehead apartments, with much of the parking underground.

That arrangement would allow more landscaped open space and smaller buildings designed to reflect the architectural character of Marblehead and Swampscott.

The Marblehead portion would include 11 affordable apartments among its 44 units. Most of the apartments throughout the development would have one or two bedrooms.

The property spans approximately four acres across Marblehead, Swampscott and Salem, although no residential buildings are proposed in Salem.

The slide focuses on building specs in Marblehead.

Several board members said the new design was preferable to the development they had previously approved.

Planning Board Chair Marc Liebman called it “just about the classiest way that you could put this amount of units in that amount of space.”

Preservation advocates offer support

Nancy Schultz, chair of Save the Glover and a member of the Swampscott Historical Commission, urged the board to support the development.

“We do not have to choose between honoring our past and welcoming our future,” Schultz said.

She described the proposal as an opportunity to provide housing while preserving a building associated with Gen. John Glover, whose Marblehead regiment played a critical role in the Revolutionary War.

Save the Glover has been working with the developer on a potential future use for the farmhouse. Preliminary ideas include museum and office space, a public meeting venue and a small café tentatively called the Popover Cafe.

The developer has discussed making the property available through a lease that would not impose a significant financial burden on the preservation organization. Details of the arrangement have not been finalized.

Schultz said the group’s goal is to restore the building and establish a lasting public use.

“Our goal is not just a building saved, but a place brought back to life,” she said.

Larry Sands, captain of Glover’s Marblehead Regiment, also spoke in support of preserving the farmhouse.

Neighbors seek additional safeguards

While preservation advocates welcomed the proposal, nearby property owners questioned whether the board was moving too quickly.

Michael Schaefer, representing the Tedesco Pond Place Condominium Trust, said residents were not necessarily opposed to the development but wanted additional, independent reviews of traffic, drainage and construction-related risks.

“I am not here to oppose the project,” Schaefer said. “What I’m concerned with is the pace of approval that’s being administered here.”

He raised concerns about traffic circulation near Vinnin Square, stormwater runoff toward Tedesco Pond and the possibility that excavation for underground parking could require blasting.

Schaefer also questioned whether water and sewer infrastructure could accommodate the development.

Other speakers, including representatives of neighboring Tedesco Country Club, sought additional assurances about the project’s potential effects on surrounding properties.

Marblehead Water and Sewer Superintendent Amy McHugh told the board that Marblehead could provide water and sewer service, although connections would be lengthy and expensive. The developer’s proposal instead anticipates service through Swampscott, where capacity questions remain.

Board members also discussed emergency access to the underground parking garage, particularly the challenges firefighters could face responding to an electric vehicle fire.

Despite those concerns, members declined to require additional independent peer reviews as a condition of their vote.

Building height remains an issue

The most significant unresolved design question involved the height of one proposed building.

Board members identified discrepancies between architectural drawings and civil engineering plans, including elevations used to calculate whether the structure complies with the district’s 42-foot height limit.

They said Building One appeared to exceed the allowable height by approximately three feet.

“This is a design review board. We approve a set of plans,” Liebman said, emphasizing the importance of receiving accurate drawings before the project proceeds.

The board required the developer to submit coordinated architectural and engineering plans demonstrating compliance with the height limit and other applicable requirements.

The vote does not constitute final authorization to begin construction.

The board scheduled further review for Dec. 8 at 7 p.m.

For supporters, the project offers a chance to accomplish two goals that once appeared incompatible: bringing new housing to Vinnin Square and saving one of the area’s significant historic buildings.

As Liebman put it, “I think that if this doesn’t happen, something far uglier will happen at some point in the future.”

By Leigh Blander

Editor Leigh Blander is an experienced TV, radio and print journalist.

Related News