Not long after the Planning Board began talking about banning data centers, the eye-rolling started on social media. A data center? Here? On what land? Marblehead is nearly built out, the argument goes, and no developer is going to shoehorn a server farm into a town this size. Banning something that will never come is a feel-good gesture.
The skeptics have a point — up to a point.
If “data center” conjures images of the windowless megastructures spreading across Virginia and Texas, Marblehead is safe. Massachusetts has largely been spared those because power here is so expensive. The projects that have made headlines in this state are enormous: a proposed campus in Westfield would have held 2.7 million square feet of floor space, and the Kraft Group’s tentative plan for Sutton would eventually draw 900 megawatts, enough to power a sizable city. Marblehead has nothing remotely like the acreage such projects demand.
But that is not the kind of facility this town should worry about. The kind we should worry about showed up this summer just across our border.
In May, Salem issued a permit to fit out roughly 8,700 square feet at the Shetland Park complex for what was described as an IT services company. In June, inspectors on a walkthrough learned the space would actually serve an AI data center company. Revised plans grew the project to nearly 12,700 square feet, with generators capable of producing 6 megawatts. The New York developer insisted it was not a data center at all but a “low-latency inference point” — servers placed close to the businesses that use them. Among the potential beneficiaries it named were GE Aerospace in Lynn, Axcelis Technologies in Beverly and Cell Signaling Technology in Danvers.
Salem’s building commissioner revoked the permit, and the Zoning Board of Appeals unanimously upheld him after a nearly three-hour hearing. As one board member put it, it was not the board’s job to “fit a square peg into a round hole.”
The new generation of AI computing does not always need a hundred acres; some of it needs a building about the size of those already standing on Tioga Way. Its business model rewards being close to customers, and Marblehead is nearly as close to Lynn, Beverly and Danvers as Shetland Park is. And it does not necessarily announce itself. The Salem project came in the door as an office fit-out.
That last point is why a clear rule matters, even if Marblehead’s zoning bylaw may already bar uses it doesn’t list. Salem’s staff and legal counsel concluded the same about their city’s zoning, and Salem still came close to hosting a data center, saved by an alert inspector and a zoning appeal. An unlisted use invites exactly the argument Salem’s developer made: that the project is really an office, or a warehouse, or light manufacturing. A bylaw that defines data centers and prohibits them takes that argument off the table.
Nor should anyone assume the state has this covered. Gov. Maura Healey’s September executive order requires a community benefits agreement before state agencies will permit a new data center — but only one with peak demand above 25 megawatts. A facility the size of Salem’s would fall far below that line. For smaller projects, local zoning is the only protection a town has.
It is also fair to ask what a multi-megawatt customer would mean for the Marblehead Municipal Light Department and the ratepayers who own it. Planning Board Chair Marc Liebman plans to meet with MMLD. We hope the department’s analysis is made public before Town Meeting.
Marblehead would not be acting alone, or even early. Salem, Haverhill and Holyoke have banned data centers. Mansfield and Northborough have capped their size. Lowell, Westfield, Shutesbury and Leominster have adopted moratoriums. Mansfield officials said they acted not because of any pending proposal but to avoid being caught flat-footed. That is not performance. It is planning.
And the cost of acting is close to nothing. A data center is not part of any realistic plan for Marblehead’s tax base. Tioga Way’s underutilized buildings were once slated for multifamily housing, but voters overturned that plan in a July 2025 referendum, and the compliance plan Town Meeting approved this May looks instead to the Tedesco Country Club and Broughton Road. With no housing overlay pointing those parcels toward another future, they remain just the sort of space a facility like Salem’s would seek. A ban forecloses little except a fight we would rather not have.
We do urge the Planning Board to do what Salem has promised to come back and do: get the definition right. Salem’s City Council struck a proposed 2-megawatt threshold and plans to revisit its language. Marblehead should write its bylaw carefully from the start — broad enough that relabeling a project as an “office” or an “inference point” won’t work, but clear that a local business’s own server room, a medical practice’s records system or the town’s IT infrastructure is not a data center. Mansfield’s approach, which sorts facilities by electricity demand rather than square footage, is worth a close look.
Will a developer ever come knocking here? Probably not. But Salem might have said the same thing until one walked in the side door. Marblehead has the chance to settle the question on its own terms, in advance, at Town Meeting in May. It should take it.
