Rail Trail makeover could cost $10M, take decades; residents urge town to preserve rustic charm

Marblehead’s Rail Trail improvement project could cost $10 million to build and take decades to complete, Community Development and Planning Director Brendan Callahan said Tuesday night, Nov. 17, during a virtual community meeting that drew nearly 100 participants.

While residents welcomed minor improvements to safety and accessibility along the popular 4.5-mile trail, many delivered a clear message: Don’t sacrifice its natural beauty in the process.

“It sounds like $10 million is turning this into a Taj Mahal that we don’t need,” said one resident who lives near the Rail Trail. She urged officials to listen to volunteers who have spent decades maintaining the trail.

Callahan outlined the project’s scope, funding and timeline, while Kathleen Fasser of Toole Design, the town’s consultant, walked residents through proposed improvements.

The project would transform much of the former railroad corridor into an 11-foot-wide, accessible shared-use path with stabilized aggregate surfaces, improved drainage, safer street crossings and new connections to surrounding neighborhoods.

But the price tag and potential changes to the trail’s character dominated much of the discussion.

The town has secured roughly $1 million in grants for design work but has no construction funding committed.

Asked when the entire project might be completed, Callahan said projects of this magnitude can take decades. Design work began approximately three years ago, and he anticipates at least three more years before all segments are fully designed.

Nearly $1 million secured — but only for design

Callahan announced several recent funding developments, including a $719,000 grant from the state’s HousingWorks Infrastructure Program and approximately $288,000 from a combination of federal, state and regional funding sources.

The money will allow Marblehead to advance design work on three major sections of the trail:

  • Swampscott branch: The 1.4-mile stretch from the Swampscott town line to Smith Street is approximately 90% designed. Final construction documents are expected by the end of 2026. The Conservation Commission issued an order of conditions Nov. 12, clearing a significant permitting hurdle.
  • Salem branch: The approximately 0.7-mile section between Lafayette Street and West Shore Drive includes Wyman Woods and the Lead Mills Conservation Area. Design work has been delayed while the town coordinates with the Marblehead Municipal Light Department on utility improvements. Design work is expected to continue through 2029.
  • Wye junction: The section connecting Bessom Street, Pleasant Street and West Shore Drive is expected to begin preliminary design in December. Green International will serve as the consultant, with design work projected to continue through October 2029.

Callahan said the town will seek additional state and federal grants to pay for construction as individual sections reach final design.

He estimated that less than $750,000 has been spent on design and construction to date, although he did not have exact figures available during the meeting.

Residents: Keep it natural

The strongest and most consistent theme during the public comment period was concern that the project could turn a beloved woodland trail into something resembling a paved sidewalk.

Don Morgan, speaking on behalf of the Marblehead Conservancy’s Trails Committee and Board of Trustees, said the organization supports improvements to make the trail usable year-round but opposes extensive clearing and manicured landscaping.

“While we support applying aggregate to approximately a 10-foot-wide surface to keep the trail usable in all seasons, we believe the existing Rail Trail’s natural beauty is in large part due to the surrounding vegetation,” Morgan said.

He added that some proposed changes, including concrete paved portions near intersections, will make “it look like a street or a sidewalk, but not like a nature trail.”

Morgan urged the town to preserve existing vegetation, remove invasive plants, protect pollinator habitat and minimize proposed structures such as kiosks, bicycle repair stations and trash barrels.

He also suggested working with the newly formed Friends of the Marblehead Rail Trail and the Marblehead Conservancy on ongoing maintenance.

Fasser emphasized that the design calls primarily for stabilized aggregate, not asphalt. The material combines crushed stone with a natural binder to create a firmer, more durable surface than traditional stone dust.

Short paved sections would be installed at road crossings to accommodate maintenance vehicles, improve visibility and prevent erosion.

The overall design also calls for native plantings, pollinator-friendly seed mixes and low-growing grasses that would require mowing only twice a year.

Fasser said the design team has adjusted its landscaping approach in response to earlier public feedback.

She also said relatively few trees would need to be removed along the Swampscott branch.

Safety concerns, especially e-bikes

Several residents raised concerns about conflicts between pedestrians and cyclists, particularly riders of increasingly popular electric bicycles.

One longtime trail runner said conditions have become more dangerous as cyclists travel faster along the corridor.

“As the trail gets smoother, cyclists of all ages can go faster, and 10 feet is not going to necessarily do it,” the resident said.

Another participant described an encounter earlier that day near Ware Pond in which two youths on an e-bike allegedly fired toy cap guns at pedestrians.

Residents questioned whether improving the trail surface would encourage even faster bicycle traffic.

Fasser acknowledged that design improvements alone cannot resolve those concerns.

“You can’t design away e-bikes. That’s an enforcement,” she said.

She said the town could consider speed-limit signage, but enforcement would ultimately be necessary.

Callahan said Police Chief Dennis King has provided some input on the project, particularly regarding bollards designed to prevent unauthorized vehicles from entering the trail. He acknowledged that additional consideration of e-bike safety may be needed.

Other residents focused on dangerous road crossings, particularly at Smith Street and Seaview Avenue.

One Smith Street abutter said she regularly witnesses near misses involving children and vehicles and urged the town to install flashing pedestrian warning lights.

Fasser said the design includes shorter crossings, improved signage, reconfigured traffic islands and collapsible bollards to improve safety.

Questions about maintenance and neighborhood access

Residents also questioned how the improved trail would be maintained and whether the town has adequately planned for ongoing expenses.

Callahan said the town’s recently approved operating override included funding for trail maintenance staff and a maintenance budget.

However, he could not provide an estimate of the annual cost of maintaining the completed project.

A draft operations and maintenance plan has been prepared but does not yet include cost projections.

Callahan also said he does not anticipate routine snow removal along the trail, although no final decision has been made.

Brian Rooney, one of the organizers of the new Friends of the Marblehead Rail Trail, questioned why certain neighborhood access points were selected for improvements while others were not.

He cited proposed connections at Ames and Garden roads, which are close together, and suggested other locations might provide greater value.

Fasser said the design team evaluated connections between the railroad corridor and public rights of way, considering accessibility, grades and available space.

Some connections would receive gently sloping paths, while others would have granite steps.

Officials said informal access points would generally remain, although eroded areas might be stabilized with vegetation or boulders.

Several homeowners whose properties border the trail also expressed concerns about privacy, drainage, tree removal and the impact of widening the path.

Fasser said drainage improvements, including rain gardens, are intended to reduce runoff problems rather than worsen them.

What’s next?

With final design of the Swampscott branch nearing completion, Callahan said the town hopes to resume work on the Salem Branch once it receives additional information from the Municipal Light Department.

Design work on the Wye Junction is expected to begin in December, with survey crews hoping to get into the field before winter weather arrives.

Callahan said additional community meetings would be held as the project reaches significant milestones, likely every several months.

Some participants urged the town to improve communication by posting updated plans, meeting notices and summaries of public feedback online.

Callahan acknowledged those concerns and said the town would work to reach more residents.

“I think I saw 99 people as part of the group at one point,” he said. “Let’s go for 200 for the next meeting.”

By Leigh Blander

Editor Leigh Blander is an experienced TV, radio and print journalist.

Related News