To show solidarity. And bear to witness.
That is how Marty Schneer, executive director of the Jewish Community Center of the North Shore, explains his purpose in joining about 40 colleagues from JCCs in the U.S. and Canada for a recent short-but-meaningful four-night trip to Israel.
This was Schneer’s eighth trip to Israel but first since what he calls “one of the most horrific events in Jewish history” — and all human history — the brutal surprise attack by Hamas on Oct. 7, which involved rape, torture and kidnapping.
“This is Dark Ages stuff; this is medieval stuff,” Schneer said. “It was hard to conceive for the Israelis, even knowing they’ve been living with skirmishes and attacks and relatively brief wars since Hamas took over in 2007.”

Laying eyes on homes destroyed in Nir Oz or the makeshift memorials at the site of the Nova music festival has taken on added importance in the weeks since the attack, during which a lack of moral clarity has crept into the public discourse, Schneer added.
“I feel a sense of responsibility to share what I saw with people who may not quite understand,” he said.
In Sderot, Schneer said he was struck by the sheer distance the terrorists had been able to travel into Israel, relatively unimpeded.
Schneer said the group spoke with a woman, displaced from Sderot and questioning whether she can ever return, who seemed to find catharsis in describing the horror of finding a naked 13-year-old girl shot in the head in the street in her small city.
The woman left the group with a challenge, according to Schneer: “Tell them our story,” meaning people back in North America.

Israeli President Isaac Herzog dropped a similar gauntlet when he welcomed the group into his residence.
“We were asking him questions, and he turned it around to everyone and said, ‘What are you going to do when you go back? What are you going to do with what you learned here? How is this trip going to have real value?’” Schneer recalled.
A stop at the site of the Nova festival was not on the group’s itinerary, but the unscheduled detour had perhaps the greatest emotional impact, according to Schneer.
For Schneer, it evoked memories of the days of Woodstock, with carefree young people gathering in the name of love and peace, only to have brutal attackers stumble upon them — Israeli authorities have come to believe Hamas had no foreknowledge of the festival — and unleash unfathomable carnage in the early morning hours.
“You’re in your tent, you’re waking up — maybe you’re not waking up; you’re sleeping off the night before — and you awake to gunfire, hand grenades, screaming, stabbing, yelling,” Schneer said.
Perhaps what was most striking was the life, the vigor and happiness plainly evident in the photos of the young people whose lives had been snuffed out, Schneer said.

“It was pretty devastating for me emotionally to see that in this bucolic setting,” he said.
Before Schneer left Marblehead, he had cleaned up a baseball cap with the Red Sox logo written in Hebrew that had been gathering dust on a shelf in his office at the JCC. Schneer had no set plan for the hat but figured he would find a worthy recipient somewhere in his travels, he explained.
He found the recipient when his group brought and shared dinner with about 20 soldiers at a makeshift base.
One of the soldiers caught his attention by goading one of his compatriots into detailing his bravery on Oct. 7, when he waded into the unfolding horror armed with just a handgun.
It turned out that the man who did not want his fellow soldier’s heroism to go unnoticed was a 36-year-old civil engineer, one of 360,000 reservists Israel called up for its response to the Hamas attack.
Despite such compulsory military service and the regular threat of violence, Israel’s population was ranked within the top five peoples in the most recent edition of the World Happiness Report, Schneer noted.
Schneer’s theory is that it relates to the fact that Israel is still a relatively new country whose people built it “out of nothing” into a technological powerhouse.
“It’s an amazing place that they have fought and died over, and it gives their life a sense of meaning and purpose,” Schneer said.
Such is the case with the new owner of Schneer’s Hebrew-inscribed Red Sox hat.

While the man showed Schneer a photograph of his wife and three “beautiful” children, he was emphatic that he was willing to continue to put his life on the line for his country, including against the more powerful Hezbollah on the northern border, if necessary.
“The bravery, the commitment, the sense of unity and country — it’s overwhelming,” Schneer said.
The group also got a grim tour of the Nir Oz kibbutz, where Hamas killed and kidnapped dozens and burned homes on Oct. 7.
The tour guide — a member of a family that had been part of the kibbutz since it was established in 1955 — showed no emotion and spoke in a monotone voice as he went house by house, detailing each family’s devastating losses.
Other encounters that left indelible impressions included one with Rabbi Doron Perez, the executive chairman of the World Mizrachi Movement, who has two sons in the military, one who had been looking forward to going on leave for his Oct. 17 wedding at the time of the Oct. 7 attacks, and another, who was wounded and captured by Hamas. The wedding went forward, even as the fate of the groom’s brother remained uncertain.
“Unfortunately, Jewish history, we’ve had a lot of horrible things happen, but the sense that [Perez] conveys is, maybe it’s been more pronounced with Jews and more long-term, but that’s life — for all of us,” Schneer said. “We have the good and the bad, and we have to try not to let the bad overwhelm the good.”
The final person the group met was Miriam Peretz, who became a renowned lecturer on Zionism and living with loss after two of her sons were killed serving in the Israel Defense Forces.
The winner of the prestigious Israel Prize in 2018 has visited the families of all of the remaining Oct. 7 hostages.
“When she was done, I had tears in my eyes, and I went to a corner of the room, took out my phone and texted my family — my daughters, my wife, my son-in-law — and told them how much I missed them and loved them,” Schneer said.
Schneer gave a presentation about his trip at the JCC on Jan. 27 but acknowledged that it was a bit like “preaching to the choir.” In the days ahead, Schneer said he would welcome the opportunity to speak with any open-minded group, even those who might not share his perspective.
