In a recent editorial, the Current suggested that the state may need to adjust the Prop 2 ½ statute to allow for tax increases in excess of 2.5% to support fixed cost increases in Marblehead and other municipalities. Unfortunately, the Current is really proposing that we ask the state to fix a fiscal problem that is entirely within our control. Arguing for a legislative solution by simply assuming that a general override cannot pass is both defeatist and lets Marbleheaders off the hook. It furthermore passes the buck to a state Legislature that almost certainly will not address Prop 2 ½ changes on the timeline necessary to help Marblehead out of its current fiscal challenge.
It’s on us to solve this problem and we have all the tools to do so.
While Marblehead’s long commitment to fiscal discipline and low taxes is noteworthy, it is important to recognize our current situation. It is virtually impossible to provide consistent levels of service in an inflationary environment while working within the constraints of Prop 2 ½. After 20 years without a general override, Marblehead, by many measures, has materially lower property taxes than surrounding and comparable municipalities. As a result, our time has come — it’s time to pay the piper.
Instead of looking to Beacon Hill for a lifeline, its incumbent on our town leaders — Select Board, School Committee – and the editorial staff of the Current to provide voters with a compelling case for a general override in 2025. If we want great schools, good infrastructure and services that make Marblehead a safe and desirable place to live, we need to be willing to pay for it. If we’re not willing to do so, we’ll get what we deserve.
Matthew Hooks
Nanepashemet Street
