Looking for answers to road and sidewalk projects

Town Administrator Thatcher Kezer says there is a “method to the madness” behind Marblehead’s much-criticized road and sidewalk work, while acknowledging that communicating that plan to residents has been a challenge.

The condition and construction of the town’s roads and sidewalks have become a heated topic on social media and in letters to the editor, with residents questioning how projects are prioritized, how money is being spent and what work is planned next. People are also complaining about bumpy patchwork, saying it creates dangerous conditions for pedestrians and cyclists.

“It is unfortunate that our town has some of the worst, potholed and construction-depressed roads of all the towns. If people do not complain the roads will not get fixed,” David Kauder, a cyclist in town, wrote to the Current.

John Alford added, “Our streets are more like scarred pathways with uneven patchworks of tar than regularly serviced roads of asphalt. You spend most of your time driving seeking to avoid holes and divots versus being in a relaxed state. It is certainly not a pleasurable experience to drive in our town.” 

In 2022, voters approved a $12.475 million debt exclusion for road paving and sidewalk reconstruction.

After several requests for an interview, DPW Supervisor Amy McHugh sent an email Friday sharing some information.

“The Department of Public Works has actively collected an extensive inventory of relevant data, coordinated with multiple utility stakeholders and developed several infrastructure plans to coordinate a comprehensive capital improvement strategy for roads and sidewalks,” McHugh wrote. “This strategic approach is designed to facilitate comprehensive street improvement projects, to be implemented based on available funding and project prioritization.” 

Asked how much of the $12 million has been spent and on what, McHugh wrote:

“To date, $4,171,339.73 has been expended from Article 11 funds. In addition, purchase orders totaling $1,622,744.58 have been committed for FY 27 work scheduled and in progress. As a result, $6,680,915.69 of Article 11 remains. Additionally, a portion of the funds covers consultant services for design and engineering, ensuring that more complex projects meet quality and safety standards.”

She also sent this work schedule:

FY 2024-2027 Pavement and sidewalk network improvements 
 »Atlantic Avenue (Gerry Street to Bubier Road) 
 »Bubier Road
 »Florence Road 
»Mystic Road 
»West Street
»State Street
»Commercial Street (Atlantic Avenue  to harbor) 
»Elm Street (Spring Street to Mugford)   

FY 2023-24 Pavement only (No sidewalk improvements) 
»Tedesco Street (Brookhouse Drive to Salem line)
»Humphrey Street (Hereford Road to Swampscott line) 
»Beacon Street (Mill Pond to Schooner Ridge) 
»Rockaway Street 
»Wyman Road 
»Ocean Avenue 
»Watson Street 
»Elm Place 
»Story Terrace 
»Countryside Lane
»Broughton Road 
»Thompson Road 
»Ida Road 
»Leo Road 
»Elizabeth Road 
»Richard Road   

FY 23-27 Sidewalk network improvements only
»West Shore Drive — ADA transitions
»Tedesco Street — New sidewalk to Salem line 
»Lafayette Street —New sidewalk to Salem line 
»Front Street — Sidewalk rehabilitation (storm damage)   

FY 23-27 Consultant support 
»15 conceptual designs for intersection improvements 
»Four preliminary design and construction estimates for complex projects
»Pavement management support 

Kezer weighs in
In a wide-ranging interview with the Current on Aug.13, Kezer and Community Development and Planning Director Brendan Callahan addressed some of the complaints, including about sidewalk changes and new curb ramps.

Kezer said the capital override is being used for “road and infrastructure work,” including sidewalks because they are part of the public right of way.

Kezer defended the town’s approach to installing curb ramps in groups rather than waiting until entire stretches of road are reconstructed.

The town faces a mix of relatively straightforward road projects and sections that require extensive engineering, he said. Some projects can be completed using standard designs, while others involve slopes, drainage, trees or other complications.

The curb ramps on West Shore Drive are an example of that approach, Kezer said. Rather than waiting for every section of the road and sidewalk to be fully designed, the town identified crossings that could be completed using standard designs and grouped them into one project.

“There’s a method to the madness,” Kezer said.

He added that a lot of coordination is required on road projects.

“You never want to put a new road on old pipes,” Kezer said, explaining that coordinating road construction with water, gas and other utility work is another factor.

Communication
Kezer acknowledged that residents are frustrated by the lack of information about the larger plan, including how much of the money allocated for road and infrastructure work has been spent and what work remains.

He said communication is an area where the town needs to improve.

One possibility he is considering is setting aside a portion of funding for communications when major projects are approved, allowing someone to focus specifically on explaining projects to residents.

The town does send out emails announcing roadwork projects coming up in the following days. To receive those emails, sign up on the town’s website at marbleheadma.gov.

Questions remain
The Current sent McHugh and Select Board Chair Dan Fox a number of questions about road and sidewalk repairs, seen below.

On Friday, McHugh responded, “I have drafted a response addressing your remaining questions; however, I will submit it to the working team for review and feedback prior to releasing it to the press.”

  • How much of the money allocated for road and infrastructure work has been spent, and on what specifically?
  • How much remains, and what projects are those remaining funds earmarked for?
  • What is Marblehead’s current road and sidewalk priority list? Is there a publicly available list showing which streets are scheduled for work and when?
  • Is there a long-term road and sidewalk capital plan showing where the town hopes to spend the remaining override money?
  • Would the town support creating a publicly accessible dashboard showing project status, cost, funding source and expected completion date?
  • Could DPW provide residents with a map showing completed, active and planned road and sidewalk projects?

For some residents, the frustration goes beyond questions about funding and project priorities — it is about the condition of the roads they use every day.

Susan Alford wrote to the Current, “We take pride in our community, but we should be ashamed of our roads. Many of the roads in Marblehead are no longer roads but rather crumbling islands of black top. The residents of Marblehead need to stand up and say enough is enough.”

By Leigh Blander

Editor Leigh Blander is an experienced TV, radio and print journalist.

Related News